Andrea's Key Lime Pies in Niceville, 15 Minutes from Destin Florida

Andrea's Key Lime Pies

A Florida Tradition

Shop Now

Call 850-687-4852 for Pickup

Key Lime Pie Small 6-8 Servings $25

$25.00 Sold out

Birthday Key Lime Pie 10" w/Chocolate Lettering-Requires Advance Notice

$28.00

Large Key Lime Party Pie $45

$45.00

The Triple Decker Key Lime Birthday Pie with Chocolate Letters-Requires Advance Notice

$48.00 Sold out

Andrea's Gluten Free Home Made Key Lime Pie 6-8 Servings-Requires Advance Notice

$30.00 Sold out

Slice of Key Lime Pie (Large)

$7.00 Sold out

Slice of Key Lime Pie (Small)

$5.00

CoConut Macaroons (Dozen)

$5.00 Sold out

CoConut Macaroons (2 for $1)

Coconut Cream Bombe Cake

6 Pack Premium Slices-Requires advance notice

$45.00

Self Service Hours 9 am -9 pm

Our Convenient Pick up system allows you to pick up on your schedule. Just Call, Text or place an Online Order and you will receive instructions! Special Birthday Orders or Party Platters need 24 hour advance notice.....

Andrea's Key Lime pies are made in Niceville, Florida

Andrea's Key Lime Pies are homemade in Niceville Outside of Destin Florida with the finest ingredients using Andrea's 25 year old cultivated recipe.

Andrea started making pies for friends and family and soon got orders from them for special events. As the demand grew so did the requests for more pies! She now makes different variations that are sold in Destin and Miramar Beach Florida. Order yours today.

Andrea's Key Lime Pies are no longer a Local's Secret

Destin is among the best places to vacation but the vacation is not complete without a piece of Andrea's Key Lime Pie! A Florida Tradition!

Self Service Hours 9 am- 9 pm

Call or Text for Instructions

The Ultimate Triple Decker Andrea's Key lime Pie

Biggest enough to satisfy even the sweetest tooth on the beach, this homemade pie is three inches high and filled with the Key Lime flavor that originated in Florida. This is a favorite among visitors along the Emerald Coast.

Order one today and we will bake it fresh. The taste of this pie will way out live your sun burn so make sure to get one today!

Testimonials

Delicious! Best Key Lime pie we have had. Looking forward to ordering more in the future. Thank you Andrea for such a scrumptious treat!
Liz B.

Wow! Amazing Pie and friendly people. Went out of their way to help us get a one to our hometown.
Madeline A.

The Strawberries really make this pie, they complement the keylime flavors. Did not want to share any.
Britney S.

Pick UP Location - (Please Schedule Pickup In Advance)

113 Bailey Dr. Ste 2

Get directions

Blog posts

Buying a whole Key lime pie from Andrea's Key Lime Pies is an affordable alternative to buying slices at Destin restaurants

May 27, 2019

Everyone visiting Destin wants to enjoy Key Lime Pie. Yet treating your family to pie at a restaurant can be very expensive, especially when priced per slice. We recommend ordering a pie from Andrea's Key Lime Pies

Read more